If you’ve discovered a coin with a strange design, double image, or off-center strike, you might be holding something worth far more than face value. Error coins—those produced by the U.S. Mint with unintentional flaws—can be extremely valuable to collectors. But not every coin dealer understands or appreciates them. That’s why it’s important to work with coin buyers who buy error coins and specialize in identifying and appraising their true worth.
In this article, we’ll explore which types of error coins are valuable, how to spot genuine mint errors, and how to find reputable buyers who are willing to pay top dollar for them.
What Are Error Coins?
Error coins are coins that were minted with production mistakes. These errors occur at the minting stage and are typically caused by mechanical malfunctions or human oversight. Unlike damaged or altered coins, error coins are authentic products of the mint and are often highly collectible due to their rarity and uniqueness.
Types of Error Coins That Coin Buyers Want
Not all errors are equal. Some are more valuable due to rarity, visibility, or historical significance. Here are the most sought-after categories among coin buyers who buy error coins:
1. Double Die Errors
A doubling of the design or inscriptions, usually visible on the date or lettering. The 1955 Lincoln cent is a famous example.
2. Off-Center Strikes
Coins struck significantly off-center—especially those missing a large portion of the design—can be highly collectible. The more extreme the offset (with the date still visible), the better.
3. Planchet Errors
Includes wrong metal composition, clipped planchets, or blank planchets. These often come from a coin being struck on a foreign or incorrect blank.
4. Die Cap Errors
When a coin becomes stuck to the die and imprints its image on following coins, creating a dramatic, “mushroom cap” appearance.
5. Brockage Errors
Caused when a previously struck coin gets stuck and acts as a die for the next strike, resulting in a mirror image on one side.
6. Mule Errors
Coins that combine mismatched obverse and reverse designs. These are exceptionally rare and can sell for thousands of dollars.
Why Are Error Coins So Valuable?
Unlike coins with wear or post-mint damage, error coins are rare mistakes from the minting process. Their value stems from:
-
Rarity – Some error types are extremely rare or even unique.
-
Collector Demand – Many collectors build entire collections based on specific error types.
-
Visual Appeal – Errors like off-center strikes or double dies are easy to see and explain, increasing collector interest.
How to Identify a Genuine Error Coin
Before you look for coin buyers who buy error coins, make sure your coin is the real deal. Here’s how:
-
Compare Against Reference Books – Use guides like the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties.
-
Use a Loupe or Magnifier – Look closely for doubling, die cracks, or other irregularities.
-
Check Weight and Dimensions – Planchet errors often result in incorrect size or weight.
-
Submit for Certification – Reputable grading services like PCGS, NGC, and ANACS can verify and grade error coins.
Be cautious—coins damaged after minting (e.g., by fire, hammering, or grinding) are not considered errors and hold little to no collector value.
Where to Find Coin Buyers Who Buy Error Coins
1. Specialized Coin Dealers
Not all dealers deal in error coins. Seek out numismatists or coin shops who explicitly advertise an interest in error coins or rare varieties.
2. Online Error Coin Buyers
There are reputable buyers and marketplaces (like eBay, GreatCollections, or independent dealers) who actively search for error coins and pay competitive rates.
3. Coin Shows
Dealers who specialize in errors often set up shop at coin conventions or collector expos. Bring your coin for in-person evaluations and offers.
4. Auction Houses
For especially rare or dramatic errors (like mules or major double dies), major auction firms may help you reach the highest-paying audience.
People Also Ask
Are error coins worth money?
Yes! Many error coins sell for much more than face value—sometimes hundreds or thousands of dollars—depending on rarity and demand.
How can I tell if my coin is an error?
Look for unusual features like doubling, missing design elements, off-center strikes, or incorrect metal composition. Use reference guides or have it examined by a professional.
Who buys error coins near me?
Check with local coin shops and ask if they specialize in errors. Many buyers also operate online and offer mail-in evaluations with insured shipping.
Is it worth getting an error coin certified?
Absolutely. Third-party certification adds credibility and often increases the value, especially for rare or high-dollar errors.
What to Look for in Coin Buyers Who Buy Error Coins
When you’re ready to sell, make sure the buyer you choose meets the following criteria:
-
✅ Experience with Error Coins – Ask if they’ve bought or sold mint errors before.
-
✅ Fair, Transparent Offers – Reputable buyers explain how they arrive at their offer.
-
✅ Option for Written Appraisal – Especially helpful if you’re selling a large or valuable collection.
-
✅ Online Reviews and References – Look for positive ratings on Google, BBB, or collector forums.
Avoid buyers who:
-
❌ Downplay the error’s significance without clear explanation
-
❌ Offer “cash only” without documentation
-
❌ Pressure you to sell immediately without comparison
How to Maximize Your Error Coin’s Value
✔ Get a Professional Opinion
If you think you have something special, get it looked at by a coin expert or submit it to a grading service for verification.
✔ Avoid Cleaning or Altering the Coin
Even error coins lose value if cleaned or mishandled.
✔ Photograph the Error Clearly
When dealing with online buyers or auctions, take high-resolution photos from multiple angles, especially of the error area.
✔ Know the Going Rate
Research recent sales of similar errors using eBay completed listings, auction records, or price guides.
Common Error Coin Examples That Sell Well
| Error Type | Example Coin | Potential Value |
|---|---|---|
| Double Die | 1955 Lincoln Cent | $500 – $1,500+ |
| Off-Center | 1969 Dime (75% off-center) | $30 – $200+ |
| Broadstrike | 1970s Quarter Broadstrike | $20 – $100+ |
| Clipped Planchet | 1983 Cent Missing Edge | $10 – $75+ |
| Mule Error | 2000 Sacagawea Dollar / State Quarter | $50,000+ |
Final Thoughts: Selling to Coin Buyers Who Buy Error Coins
If you’ve come across a mint mistake, you might be holding a valuable collectible. But not every coin dealer understands error coins—or pays fairly for them. That’s why it’s essential to seek out coin buyers who buy error coins and appreciate the rarity and demand behind these fascinating numismatic oddities.
With a bit of research and the right buyer, your error coin could bring in far more than face value—and maybe even more than its weight in silver or gold.
Think You Have an Error Coin Worth Selling?
Reach out to our team of expert coin buyers who buy error coins for a free consultation or appraisal. We specialize in evaluating mint errors, die varieties, and rare anomalies—and we’re ready to offer you a fair, competitive price today.